Rules as published by each firm
CFD vs FUTURES
Static Balance-Based vs End-of-Day (EOD) Trailing
☪ Islamic / Swap-Free Ready
The5ers vs TradeDay
Which of these two is likelier to end your account, and why — compared rule by rule from what each firm publishes.
Short answer
- The drawdown works differently, and that is the difference that matters. The5ers' loss limit is fixed to your starting balance and never moves; TradeDay's steps up at each daily close and never steps back down. TradeDay: A floor set at last night's close is still enforced live all session, so you can be liquidated intraday by a level you never saw move.
- Daily loss cap: The5ers 5%, TradeDay 2.5%.
- Minimum trading days: The5ers 3 days, TradeDay 5 days — this sets the earliest you can finish, however fast you hit the target.
- Overnight and weekend: The5ers lets you hold; TradeDay requires you flat before the session closes, so a swing plan does not fit it.
- Entry cost: The5ers from $39, TradeDay from $99.
Figures below are what each firm publishes. Confirm them on the firm's own site before paying for an evaluation — these rules change without notice.
The5ers
CFD • Max $500,000
Drawdown Model
Static Balance-Based
Profit Split
80% - 100%
Starting Price
$39
Min Trading Days
3 Days
TradeDay
FUTURES • Max $250,000
Drawdown Model
End-of-Day (EOD) Trailing
Profit Split
90% - 100%
Starting Price
$99
Min Trading Days
5 Days
Side-by-Side Specifications Matrix
Every figure below is taken from the firm's own published rules. Check the source and date under the table before you size a position on it — prop firm rules change without notice.
| Evaluation Parameter | The5ers | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Asset Class / Market | CFD | FUTURES |
| Drawdown Calculation Type | Static Balance-Based The total-loss cap is static — a fixed percentage of the starting balance that never trails — but the daily limit is recalculated every day off the previous day's close, so it is not a fixed dollar figure. |
End-of-Day (EOD) Trailing |
| Max Daily Loss | 5.0% 5% on High Stakes, measured off the higher of the previous day's closing balance or equity and reset at 00:00 UTC+3; Hyper Growth and Pro Growth use 3%, and the firm's own 2-Step Plan FAQ also states 3%. |
2.5% Left unchanged under the refuted-verdict rule — see left_uncorrected; the only loss-based failure condition TradeDay publishes is the Maximum Drawdown. |
| Max Overall Loss | 10.0% 10% of the initial balance on High Stakes, fixed when the account opens and never trailing; Hyper Growth and Pro Growth stop out at 6%, and Bootcamp uses 5% on steps 1-3 and 4% once funded. |
3% 3% is the $100k trailing max drawdown ($97,000 floor); the $25k and $50k accounts are 4% ($1,000 / $2,000) and the $150k is 3% ($4,500), identical across Quick Pay and Fast Pass. |
| Profit Split | 80% - 100% | 90% - 100% |
| Minimum Trading Days | 3 Days High Stakes needs 3 profitable days at Step 1, at Step 2 and again at every scaling step, where a profitable day means closed trades netting at least 0.5% of the initial balance. |
5 Days 5 is the Quick Pay figure; TradeDay's own pages contradict each other on Fast Pass (its knowledge base says 3, its marketing pages say none), so this was left unchanged. |
| News Trading Policy | ✓ New orders may not be executed from 2 minutes before to 2 minutes after high-impact news on the High Stakes programme; holding existing positions through news is allowed, and any profit made inside that window is deducted from the account and does not count toward the profit target | ✓ TradeDay auto-liquidates every open position 2 minutes before and reopens 2 minutes after its Tier-1 releases (FOMC, CPI, non-farm payrolls, crude oil and natural gas inventories, crop production); accidental breaches are forgiven, repeated abuse loses the account |
| Weekend & Overnight Holding | ✓ Permitted (Overnight and weekend holding allowed with no restrictions) | ✗ Flat by Close (Overnight and multi-session holding is allowed — a position opened in one session must be closed before the next session's close, and all positions are auto-liquidated 10 minutes before each daily close) |
| Supported Platforms | MT5, cTrader, TradingView | Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView |
| Payout Schedule | Bi-weekly or on-demand after 14 days | On request with no buffer and no minimum trading period on Quick Pay; requests submitted before 5:30pm ET are processed the next business day, minimum $250 Cut-off is 5:30pm ET for next-business-day processing; the repo's earlier 'same-day once the safety buffer is met' matched nothing on TradeDay's own pages. |
| First Payout Eligibility | 14 days from funding First withdrawal 14 days after the funded account is activated, then every 2 weeks from the last approved one, with $150 minimum profit required to request a payout. |
Quick Pay: none — withdraw from any positive balance; Fast Pass: 5 profitable trading days, each clearing a per-tier minimum profit ($100/$150/$200/$250 for $25k/$50k/$100k/$150k) The 5 Fast Pass days need not be consecutive, and the balance must also be above the starting balance with net profit since the last payout. |
| Consistency Rule | No restrictive lot-size or profit consistency rule | Evaluation only: no single day may exceed 30% of total profit to date on Quick Pay (45% on Fast Pass); a breach raises the profit target instead of failing the account, and no consistency rule applies to Funded Sim or Funded Live Measured as one day's P&L against total profit to date; separately, Fast Pass Funded Sim accounts opened on or after 26 July 2026 must also pass a 45% single-day check before a payout is released. |
| Islamic / Swap-Free Option | ✓ Native Swap-Free Option Native Swap-Free account option selectable upon registration with zero administration fee markups |
✓ Inherently Swap-Free (CME Futures) Inherently Swap-Free (Regulated CME futures exchange model; zero overnight holding and zero swap financing) |
| US Residents Accepted | ✗ Restricted | ✓ Accepted |
| Maximum Capital Allocation | $500,000 | $250,000 |
Where these figures come from. Read from The5ers' own published rules on : High Stakes daily/total loss mechanics and 00 · High Stakes minimum profitable days table and · Platform availability by residency · MetaQuotes platforms prohibited for US residen · Full banned-strategy list and the termination, · 14-day first withdrawal, 2-week cadence therea · Bootcamp per-step max loss (5% steps 1-3, 4% f · Hyper Growth / Pro Growth 6% stop-out and 3% d · 2-Step Plan daily loss limit stated as 3% of t. Prop firm rules change without notice — confirm on the firm's own site before you pay for an evaluation.
Where these figures come from. Read from TradeDay's own published rules on : Maximum drawdown mechanism and the $100k examp · Pricing/programme tables giving the per-size d · Tier-1 news auto-liquidation window (2 minutes · Consistency objective · Evaluation objectives per programme; cross-che · Funded ruleset · Overnight holding permitted across sessions; 1 · Fast Pass payout gate · Quick Pay payout policy · Payout processing timing · Account limits and the hedging prohibition wit · Withdrawal mismanagement clause tying large/fr · Section 23 Prohibited Conduct. Prop firm rules change without notice — confirm on the firm's own site before you pay for an evaluation.
What can end the account even if you are profitable
These are the rules people usually find out about after a payout is refused.
- The5ers: You cannot open or close an order in the four-minute window running from two minutes before to two minutes after a high-impact news release, and if you do, the profit from it is taken off your account and does not count toward your target while the loss still counts against you. source
- The5ers: Copy trading, running an expert advisor whose source code you do not own, sharing or reselling your account, or paying someone to pass a challenge for you gets the account terminated, any profit or refund you were owed withheld, and you permanently banned from The5ers. source
- The5ers: Arbitrage, tick scalping, high-frequency trades lasting seconds, bracketing stop orders around news, hedging the same instrument across accounts, and gambling-sized or one-directional bets carry the same penalty: account closed, profit and refund forfeited, permanent ban. source
- The5ers: You must produce three separate profitable days, each closing at least 0.5% of your starting balance in profit, to clear Step 1, to clear Step 2 and again at every scaling step — hitting the profit target in one big day is not enough to pass. source
- The5ers: If you place no trades for 30 days in a row on an evaluation account, or 60 days in a row on a funded account, The5ers expires the account automatically and you lose it without breaking any trading rule. source
- The5ers: You cannot take any money out for the first 14 days after your funded account is activated, you need at least $150 of profit to request a payout, and after that each request comes two weeks after your last approved one. source
- TradeDay: TradeDay closes every open position 2 minutes before and 2 minutes after its own Tier-1 data releases (FOMC, CPI, non-farm payrolls, crude oil and natural gas inventories, crop production reports); one accidental breach is forgiven, but traders who keep trading through the window lose the account. source
- TradeDay: Once you are funded, trading within 2% of an exchange price limit loses you the funded account immediately — TradeDay forgives accidental slips on trading times, products and position sizes, but states no such grace period for this rule. source
- TradeDay: If an automated or high-frequency strategy fires more than 200 trades in a single day, TradeDay can delete that trading day and all of its profits, restart or close the account, or ban you from the platform entirely. source
- TradeDay: Going long a product in one of your TradeDay accounts while short the same product in another counts as hedging: you are offboarded and suspended, and you forfeit every dollar of profit sitting in all of your funded accounts, not just the account that hedged. source
- TradeDay: Signing up more than once under different usernames or email addresses is prohibited conduct under Section 23 of the terms, which lets TradeDay delete the trading day and all profits, restart or close the account, or ban you from the service. source
- TradeDay: During the evaluation no single day may account for more than 30% of your total profit so far on Quick Pay (45% on Fast Pass); going over does not fail you, but your profit target rises until that big day is diluted back under the cap. source
- TradeDay: On Fast Pass you cannot take your first payout until you have 5 profitable trading days that each clear a minimum profit for your account size ($100 on $25k, $150 on $50k, $200 on $100k, $250 on $150k), with the balance above your starting balance. source
- TradeDay: On Fast Pass funded sim accounts opened on or after 26 July 2026, a payout is also withheld if any single day makes up more than 45% of your total gross profit. source
- TradeDay: You cannot hold a position into the daily close: TradeDay auto-liquidates everything 10 minutes before the close of the product you are trading, and funded traders are required to be flat by then. source
- TradeDay: Withdrawing often or in large amounts so that your balance sits close to the trailing drawdown can be judged as mismanaging the account, and TradeDay may then refuse to invite you back for another evaluation. source
Drawdown Architecture: The5ers vs TradeDay
The fundamental differentiator between The5ers and TradeDay lies in how risk and liquidation thresholds are tracked:
The5ers: Static Balance-Based
The5ers applies a Static Balance-Based approach. Under this structure, your stop loss floor is anchored to balance intervals. This ensures that temporary floating open profits do not pull your stop loss floor higher in real-time.
TradeDay: End-of-Day (EOD) Trailing
TradeDay implements a End-of-Day (EOD) Trailing model. This provides traders with full intraday flexibility without the fear of open spikes ratcheting up their liquidation point.
The Trader's Verdict: Which Firm Should You Choose?
Depending on your trading style, asset preference, and capital requirements, here is how our research team segments the two providers:
Choose The5ers if you:
- Want Static Balance-Based risk management.
- Trade primarily CFD instruments with MT5, cTrader, TradingView.
- Value Traders looking for instant funding programs, low entry fee Bootcamps, and scaling that reaches $4,000,000 on Bootcamp (High Stakes and Hyper Growth both cap at $500,000).
- Want the ability to hold swing positions over weekends and economic news releases.
- Seek up to $500,000 in maximum scaling capital.
Choose TradeDay if you:
- Prefer End-of-Day (EOD) Trailing execution terms.
- Trade FUTURES via Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView.
- Value Serious futures traders seeking direct CME-regulated broker funding with no payout buffer and next-business-day disbursements.
- Require strict intraday liquidity and same-day/daily payout options.
- Want access to starting entry fees at $99.
Frequently Asked Questions: The5ers vs TradeDay
Which firm offers a better drawdown model between The5ers and TradeDay?
The5ers uses Static Balance-Based, while TradeDay utilizes End-of-Day (EOD) Trailing.
Traders who hold positions through volatile pullbacks typically favor The5ers, whereas scalpers capitalizing on quick momentum benefit from TradeDay.
Can I trade both The5ers and TradeDay accounts at the same time?
Yes. Many professional prop traders run trade copiers (such as Replikanto for NinjaTrader futures, or Social Trader Tools for MT4/MT5 CFDs) to mirror trades across both The5ers and TradeDay simultaneously, diversifying broker risk and maximizing total payout potential.
Which prop firm has faster payout disbursements?
The5ers processes payouts on a Bi-weekly or on-demand after 14 days basis (14 days from funding), whereas TradeDay operates on a On request with no buffer and no minimum trading period on Quick Pay; requests submitted before 5:30pm ET are processed the next business day, minimum $250 schedule (Quick Pay: none — withdraw from any positive balance; Fast Pass: 5 profitable trading days, each clearing a per-tier minimum profit ($100/$150/$200/$250 for $25k/$50k/$100k/$150k)). Both platforms support crypto and direct bank transfers.